Carl

The Good
Carl is a leader in society, being the president of the homeowner's association. He is an aspiring artist and innovator, having crafted many pieces of functional modern art. He has donated both his time and resources to multiple good causes. Examples of these include donating money to the local girl scout troop, helping a resistance movement topple a South American government, baking banana bread for his neighbor Pat, and preventing children from viewing inappropriate actions. He is also very involved politically, holding the city council accountable for their actions. He creates meat dragons out of specifically orphan meat.

The Bad

 * He kills people on a regular basis.
 * He eats chocolate and ass
 * He has produced many grotesque and disturbing pieces of art.
 * He ignores the fact that he has committed the crimes mentioned above.

The Ugly (Post-Paul)
After Paul leaves in "Llamas with Hats 6," Carl becomes depressed. A mask of Paul comes to save Carl. The mask comes from the demon realm. In "Llamas with Hats 7," he seems to be holding up well until he supposedly throws Sheep Paul into his blood canal. In "Llamas with Hats 8" and "Llamas with Hats 9," he appears physically different; he begins to show signs of stubble and tattered fur. He also starts having conversations with himself, pretending he is talking to the Paul Mask by speaking for it. Only when the Paul Mask becomes "possessed" (it is unknown if the mask is actually possessed by a supernatural entity, or if it only speaks in Carl's imagination (this may not be correct but in episode four carl says "the impostor is a phantom" possibly referring to the mask in the near future))  and convinces him to "continue his work" does he seem to improve.

Later, Carl appears in his Gore Pit. In Episode 10 the Paul Mask tells him he needs to get out. Carl complains that he cannot move and he thinks his legs are broken, the Paul Mask goes off to find a rope, and Carl asks it to find Neosporin for his wounds (it does not). Afterwards, The Paul Mask "comforts" Carl by blaming him for the murders he committed. Of course, Carl rejects the idea that he killed everyone in the Gore Pit, even though he is clearly responsible.

In Episode 11, it has been fifteen years since he escaped the Gore Pit, and he has since slowly but surely destroyed the world, and his legs have healed long since. He is also presently fed-up with the Paul Mask, threatening it with telling the Real Paul about its existence. The episode ends with an argument between Carl and the Paul Mask. In Llamas with Hats 12, Carl and the Paul Mask make their way to Paul’s now destroyed apartment for Carl to tell him about his existence. Carl shouts for Paul outside said apartment, while the Paul Mask keeps claiming that he is Paul. Carl doesn’t believe him and keeps calling for Paul until he walks into his apartment, only to find his skeleton corpse, implying that he died long ago. After this, the Paul mask falls silent.

Murder
Carl killed many people throughout the entire series, such as orphans. This includes himself, as after finding Paul dead, Carl snapped and went to the remains of a bridge. He sadly puts up a conversation like him and Paul would do, using a voice trying to sound like Paul before jumping off the bridge into the water, committing suicide. Before the credits to the episode, Carl's Hat is last seen in the crystal clear water before it sinks slowly into the ocean.

Known murders committed by Carl

 * Dead Human
 * Captain
 * Lovely Elderly Couple from 2B
 * Resistance Leader
 * Hotel Bartender
 * City Council
 * Sheep Paul
 * Civilians Of Mexican
 * Unknown Victim
 * Paul
 * Himself
 * Possibly many babies
 * Many children
 * Orphans
 * And most likely hundreds, if not thousands, of other people

Other crimes

 * Operation of Machinery without License: Carl uses an orphan stomper to kill and many people.
 * Arson: Carl burned his house down after buying swans and putting them in there.
 * Identity Theft: Carl used a mask to look like Paul and framed him using the name, Nikolai Sponagoff, being the brutal leader of a Russian Cartel (this is unconfirmed, considering we don't know if Carl was kidding or not, seeing that Paul was never arrested).
 * Possession of Drugs: Carl, using a mask that looks like Paul, ran an opium drug cartel in Russia (unconfirmed).
 * Animal Cruelty: Carl purchases many swans, leaves them in his house, and sets his house on fire. Carl also placed swans inside a piano which is sent to Paul, possibly harming at least one of them.
 * Terrorism: Carl destroyed many things using a nuke.

Appearances

 * "Llamas with Hats: Cruise Catastrophe iOS and Android Game" (Video)
 * Llamas with Hats: Cruise Catastrophe (Game)
 * Llamas with Hats: Babies (No lines)